Growing up, I played baseball with a guy named Jonathan. Jonathan was a naturally gifted athlete. He could throw a football with ease, he could hit three pointers from anywhere, and he threw 90mph+ as a pitcher.
Jonathan was an incredible athlete, but there was one issue. He had no idea how to package all of his talent together. He was all raw athleticism, but his mindset was a disaster; he hated practicing, he didn't work out, and he couldn't have cared less about the outcome of the games he was playing in, oddly enough.
Jonathan had all of the talents and skills you wanted, but it was almost like they were placed in a blender and shaken up in a way that caused him to be amazing and awful all at once. When we were younger, it was sort of a fun and games type of thing, but as we got into high school, his lack of preparation and his lack of give a fuck really started to shine through.
Free Daily Newsletter
Enjoying this? Get more like it.
Scott publishes every day. Drop your email and it lands in your inbox.
No spam. One article per day. Unsubscribe any time.
He went from a guy who could have easily played college baseball to being kicked off his team. He would show up and screw off during practice, and then he wouldn't take drills seriously, eventually getting yelled at by our coaching staff. The thing is, we loved him; he was funny and engaging, but all of the things that mattered around the sport just didn't resonate with him.
He would go from almost getting kicked out of practice on a Thursday to throwing a no-hitter in the second game of a doubleheader on Friday. The kid was all raw, all gifted. In fact, we all wished we had a fraction of the athleticism he had.
By the time we were getting to our Senior year of high school, he had skipped around a few schools, often out of baseball, and back in it. He went from being a guy who should have been scouted to play at a prominent college to being an afterthought because his grades were poor, no coach would back him for the future, and his act had sort of grown tired.
It was a shame to watch because Jonathan had everything you wanted as an athlete, except the mindset side, which ultimately glues it all together.
I've seen this time and time again in the workplace where you have this gifted mind, but for some reason, the individual just can't piece it all together. They show up late, they argue with leadership, they don't care about outcomes. I've seen it in some brilliant minds, too. People who could have incredible careers and just don't give a fuck. And maybe that's ok, because that's their decision, but it's hard to watch talent get wasted.
I've seen the smartest person in the room who can't manage their emotions. The most creative thinker who never executes. The high performer who refuses to be coached. It's not a skill problem; it's a standards problem. It's the gap between what someone is capable of and what they're actually willing to do consistently. That gap is where most potential goes to die, and it has nothing to do with intelligence, background, or opportunity.
There are a lot of Jonathans out there. Insanely talented, fun to be around, full of potential, and nowhere near where they should be. Unfortunately, those are also the people who tend to be frustrated that they're not where they want to be, and they just can't figure out how to put it all together.
It's not because they lacked the talent or the drive or the desire, but because they never decided it mattered enough to lock in. Talent opens the door, but mindset is what keeps you in the room.